Filing a Capital Dividend Election Correctly in Canada

Introduction

A private corporation with a positive capital dividend account can distribute that amount to its Canadian resident shareholders without tax. The balance alone does not achieve this. An election must be filed, and it must be filed correctly.

Form T2054 is that election. It is a short form, which contributes to the problem, because the brevity of the document conceals how much turns on getting it right.

An election filed late attracts a penalty. An election for an amount the account cannot support attracts a tax of sixty percent on the excess. Both outcomes are avoidable, and both occur with some regularity.

What the Election Does

Without an election, a dividend paid by a corporation is an ordinary taxable dividend in the hands of the shareholder.

The election changes that characterization. Where it is validly made, the dividend is not included in the income of a Canadian resident shareholder, and no tax slip is issued for it.

The election applies to the full amount of the dividend in respect of which it is made. It is not a partial designation applied to part of a larger dividend, which is why the amount declared and the amount elected need to correspond.

The Documents Required

Three items go together, and an election missing any of them is incomplete.

The first is the form itself, identifying the corporation, the amount of the dividend, and the date it becomes payable.

The second is a certified copy of the directors’ resolution authorizing the dividend. The resolution should state the amount, identify the dividend as a capital dividend, and specify the date on which it becomes payable.

The third is Schedule 89, which summarizes the components of the account balance supporting the election.

Corporations in Quebec have an additional provincial filing, which accompanies copies of the federal form and schedule.

The Filing Deadline

The election must be filed by the earlier of two dates. The first is the day the dividend becomes payable. The second is the first day on which any part of the dividend is paid.

The practical implication is that the election is a before or at the time document, not an after the fact one. It does not travel with the corporate tax return for the year.

This catches corporations whose practice is to declare dividends and attend to filings at year end. By then the deadline has passed.

A late election is still possible, but it carries a penalty calculated under the relevant provision, and the penalty applies for the period of lateness.

Sequencing the Steps

The order in which the steps are performed determines whether the election is supportable.

A workable sequence is:

• Confirm the account balance and obtain verification before anything is declared
• Prepare the directors’ resolution, stating the amount and the date payable
• File the election with the resolution and the supporting schedule by the deadline
• Pay the dividend on or after the date stated in the resolution

The most common sequencing failure is declaring first and calculating afterward, which leaves the corporation committed to an amount it may not be able to support.

Verifying the Balance First

The balance is the corporation’s own responsibility to calculate, and the Canada Revenue Agency does not prepare it.

It is, however, possible to obtain the Agency’s own figure before filing. Schedule 89 can be submitted on its own as a balance verification request, and balances and component details are available through the corporation’s online business account where a prior filing exists.

Obtaining that verification before a significant election is worthwhile. It takes time, which is another reason to begin well before a dividend is contemplated rather than in the days before a deadline.

The Agency has indicated that it provides this verification as a courtesy. It is a useful cross check, not a transfer of responsibility.

When the Elected Amount Is Too High

This is the outcome the process exists to prevent.

Where the elected amount exceeds the available balance, the excess is not a capital dividend. The corporation becomes liable for a tax of sixty percent of the excess, and interest runs on that amount from the date the election was made.

The exposure does not stop at the corporation. Shareholders who received the excess portion may be liable for their proportionate share.

A remedy exists. The corporation may elect to treat the excess as a separate taxable dividend, which avoids the sixty percent tax. That election must be made within ninety days of the date the assessment is sent, and the Agency has issued a form for the purpose.

The remedy requires shareholder concurrence and leaves everyone worse off than a correct election would have, because the amount becomes taxable in the shareholders’ hands. It repairs the damage rather than preventing it.

Elections Involving Received Dividends

Where the balance includes a capital dividend received from another corporation, the form asks about it specifically.

This creates a dependency worth understanding. The receiving corporation’s balance now rests in part on whether the paying corporation’s own election was valid.

In group structures where dividends move between related corporations, the documentation for each step should be retained together rather than held separately by each entity.

Practical Points That Prevent Problems

A few habits reduce the risk considerably.

Begin the calculation well before the dividend is needed, because reconstructing a history of capital gains, losses, insurance proceeds and prior dividends takes longer than expected in a corporation of any age.

Confirm the adjusted cost basis of any insurance policy in writing from the insurer rather than estimating it, since this affects the insurance component directly.

Keep every prior resolution and election together in one place. For older corporations, this history is frequently the hardest part to reconstruct, and it is entirely within the corporation’s control to maintain.

Where a corporation has amalgamated, assemble the equivalent information for each predecessor.

Common Filing Errors

Several errors recur.

Filing after the dividend has been paid, which puts the election into late territory and triggers a penalty.

Submitting the form without the certified resolution or the supporting schedule.

Electing an amount based on an estimate rather than a verified balance.

Declaring the dividend before the calculation is complete, which removes the corporation’s flexibility to adjust the amount.

Overlooking capital losses, which reduce the balance and are easy to miss where they arose in years when no dividend was contemplated.

Treating the election as part of the year end compliance cycle rather than as a transaction document with its own deadline.

Conclusion

Form T2054 converts an ordinary dividend into a capital dividend, and the conversion only works if the election is complete and timely.

It must be accompanied by a certified copy of the directors’ resolution and by a schedule supporting the account balance, and it must be filed by the earlier of the day the dividend becomes payable and the first day any part of it is paid.

A late election remains possible but attracts a penalty. An election exceeding the available balance attracts a tax of sixty percent on the excess, with a remedial election available within ninety days of assessment that leaves the parties in a worse position than a correct filing would have.

The balance can be verified against the Agency’s records before filing, and that verification should be obtained before any significant election.

The sequence matters as much as the arithmetic. Confirm the balance, then resolve, then file, then pay.

Tax Partners can assist you in structuring your affairs properly and ensuring full compliance while optimizing your tax position.

This article is written for educational purposes.
 

Should you have any inquiries, please do not hesitate to contact us at (905) 836-8755, via email at info@taxpartners.ca, or by visiting our website at www.taxpartners.ca.
 

Tax Partners has been operational since 1981 and is recognized as one of the leading tax and accounting firms in North America. Contact us today for a FREE initial consultation appointment.