Cash Value Life Insurance in Canada: How It Works
Introduction
Permanent life insurance in Canada does more than pay a death benefit. Most permanent contracts also accumulate a cash value.
The policy owner can access that value during their lifetime. The common routes are withdrawals, policy loans, or using the policy as collateral for third party borrowing.
That accumulation feature is why life insurance appears in planning conversations that have nothing to do with protecting dependants. Business owners, incorporated professionals and families with significant assets often hold permanent policies as part of a broader tax and estate strategy.
The tax rules that govern cash value are specific. They do not work the way many policy owners assume, and understanding them before entering a contract is considerably easier than unwinding a misunderstanding years later.
What Cash Value Actually Is
Cash value is the amount that accumulates inside a permanent life insurance policy over and above the pure cost of providing the death benefit.
Each premium payment is allocated between the cost of insurance, the insurer’s expenses, and the amount directed to accumulation.
In the early years, the first two components absorb most of the premium. This is why cash values are typically minimal at the outset and often sit below cumulative premiums paid for several years.
Term life insurance does not accumulate cash value. Only permanent contracts do, principally participating whole life, non-participating whole life, and universal life.
The cash surrender value is the amount the policy owner would receive on surrendering the contract. Subsection 148(9) of the Income Tax Act defines it as computed without regard to any policy loans, and without regard to policy dividends other than paid-up additions.
The Exempt Policy Rules
The central tax advantage of cash value life insurance is that growth inside the policy is not subject to annual accrual taxation. This applies provided the policy qualifies as an exempt policy.
A policy is tested against a prescribed benchmark known as the exempt test policy. Where accumulation stays within the legislated parameters, the policy is exempt and the growth is not taxed year by year.
Where a policy fails the test and becomes non-exempt, the growth in cash value in excess of the growth in adjusted cost basis becomes subject to annual taxation.
Non-exempt policies are rarely issued in Canada. Insurers generally build in contractual and administrative measures to keep policies onside.
The rules governing the exempt test were modernized effective January 1, 2017. The changes generally reduced the amount that can accumulate on a tax exempt basis over the lifetime of a permanent policy.
Policies issued before that date are generally grandfathered under the prior rules. That status can be lost, however, where certain changes are made to the policy afterward, including adding coverage or increasing the amount of existing insurance.
Adjusted Cost Basis
The adjusted cost basis of a policy is the figure that determines the tax consequence of almost every transaction involving the contract. It is not the same as premiums paid.
Subsection 148(9) sets out a formula. In broad terms, the adjusted cost basis is increased by amounts such as the cost of acquiring the interest, premiums paid, and amounts previously included in income on a prior disposition.
It is reduced by amounts including prior proceeds of disposition and, significantly, the net cost of pure insurance.
The net cost of pure insurance is a prescribed annual amount reflecting the mortality cost of the coverage. Because it is deducted each year and increases with the age of the insured, the adjusted cost basis of a long held policy typically rises in the early and middle years and then declines, often approaching nil in later years.
This pattern matters. A policy that would have produced little or no taxable gain on surrender at year fifteen may produce a substantial one at year forty, even if the cash value has grown steadily throughout.
What Counts as a Disposition
Subsection 148(9) defines disposition broadly for life insurance purposes. It includes a surrender of the interest, a policy loan made after March 31, 1978, and the dissolution of the interest on maturity of the policy.
It does not include an assignment of the policy for the purpose of securing a debt or loan other than a policy loan. This distinction is the basis for collateral lending arrangements, where a lender takes security over the policy rather than the owner borrowing from the insurer directly.
It also does not include a payment made as a consequence of death under an exempt policy. This is why the death benefit of an exempt policy is received free of tax.
Tax on Accessing Cash Value
Where a disposition occurs, subsection 148(1) requires the policyholder to include in income the amount by which the proceeds of disposition exceed the adjusted cost basis of the interest immediately before the disposition.
This amount is called a policy gain. It is included in income in full. It is ordinary income, not a capital gain, and it does not benefit from the inclusion rate that applies to capital property.
On a partial surrender, subsection 148(4) prorates the adjusted cost basis. Only the portion of the adjusted cost basis that relates to the amount withdrawn is applied against the proceeds.
As a result, a partial withdrawal can produce a taxable amount even where the total adjusted cost basis exceeds the amount taken.
Policy dividends are treated as a disposition under paragraph 148(2)(a). Where the dividend is applied immediately to pay a premium or repay a policy loan under the terms of the contract, that portion is excluded from the proceeds, which generally defers any tax consequence.
Policy Loans Compared With Collateral Loans
The distinction between these two methods of accessing cash value is one of the most consequential in this area.
A policy loan is an advance from the insurer under the terms of the contract. It is a disposition.
The proceeds are generally the lesser of the amount of the loan and the excess of the cash surrender value over outstanding policy loans. A taxable policy gain arises where those proceeds exceed the adjusted cost basis.
A collateral loan is borrowing from a third party lender, typically a bank, with the policy assigned as security. Because that assignment is expressly excluded from the definition of disposition, no policy gain arises at the time of borrowing.
These arrangements carry their own considerations, including interest costs, lending terms that may change, and the lender’s right to call the loan. They are not simply a tax free version of a policy loan.
Treatment at Death
Where the life insured dies and the policy is exempt, the death benefit is received free of tax by the named beneficiary.
Where a private corporation owns the policy and receives the proceeds, the amount by which those proceeds exceed the adjusted cost basis of the policy to the corporation is credited to the corporation’s capital dividend account under the definition in subsection 89(1).
That credit can then support a tax free capital dividend to shareholders.
This is the reason adjusted cost basis matters so much in corporate planning. A higher adjusted cost basis at death means a smaller capital dividend account credit and less value that can be extracted from the corporation tax free.
Premium Deductibility
Life insurance premiums are generally not deductible, whether paid personally or by a corporation.
A limited exception exists under paragraph 20(1)(e.2). It may permit a deduction for a portion of premiums where a policy is assigned as collateral for a loan from a restricted financial institution and certain conditions are met.
Owners should not assume a deduction is available. The conditions are specific and the deductible amount is limited to the net cost of pure insurance related to the borrowing.
Common Planning Mistakes
Several errors recur with cash value policies.
The most common is treating cash value as equivalent to a savings account balance available without consequence. Accessing it through a surrender or policy loan is a disposition with a measurable tax result.
Another is assuming the adjusted cost basis equals premiums paid. This overstates the tax free room available and understates the eventual gain.
A third is taking a policy loan where a collateral arrangement would have produced a better result, or the reverse, without comparing the two.
Finally, owners of pre-2017 policies sometimes request changes without advice and lose grandfathered status under the prior exempt test rules.
Conclusion
Cash value life insurance allows accumulation inside a policy without annual accrual taxation, provided the contract qualifies as an exempt policy. The rules governing that test were modernized effective January 1, 2017.
The adjusted cost basis governs the tax result of almost every transaction involving the policy. Because it is reduced annually by the net cost of pure insurance, it generally declines in later years and increases the taxable gain on a lifetime disposition.
Surrenders, partial withdrawals and policy loans are all dispositions that produce fully taxable policy gains. An assignment of the policy as collateral for a third party loan is not.
At death, an exempt policy pays free of tax. Where a private corporation owns the policy, the proceeds less the adjusted cost basis generate a capital dividend account credit.
These mechanics should be understood before a policy is purchased rather than when value is first accessed.
Tax Partners can assist you in structuring your affairs properly and ensuring full compliance while optimizing your tax position.
This article is written for educational purposes.
Should you have any inquiries, please do not hesitate to contact us at (905) 836-8755, via email at info@taxpartners.ca, or by visiting our website at www.taxpartners.ca.
Tax Partners has been operational since 1981 and is recognized as one of the leading tax and accounting firms in North America. Contact us today for a FREE initial consultation appointment.