Taxation of RSUs vs. Stock Options: What’s the Difference?

Introduction

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) and stock options are two popular forms of equity compensation offered by companies to employees. While both provide a way to acquire company shares, they have different taxation rules, making it essential to understand their implications. This article explores how RSUs and stock options are taxed, their key differences, and strategies to manage tax liabilities effectively.

What Are RSUs?

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) are a form of employee compensation where an employer grants shares to an employee, typically with a vesting schedule. RSUs do not have immediate value but become taxable once they vest and the employee gains full ownership.

Tax Treatment of RSUs

1. At Vesting
   • When RSUs vest, they are considered ordinary income.
   • The fair market value (FMV) of the vested shares on the vesting date is included in the employee’s taxable income.
   • Taxes such as federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare are deducted at the time of vesting.
2. Upon Sale of Shares
   • If the employee sells the RSUs immediately upon vesting, there is little to no capital gains tax since the FMV is already taxed as income.
   • If the employee holds the shares after vesting, any gain or loss upon sale is subject to capital gains tax (short-term or long-term, depending on the holding period).

Example:
Sarah receives 1,000 RSUs that vest when the stock price is $50 per share. She recognizes $50,000 as taxable income. If she sells the shares later at $60 per share, the additional $10,000 is subject to capital gains tax.

What Are Stock Options?

Stock options give employees the right to purchase company shares at a predetermined price, known as the exercise price or strike price. There are two main types of stock options:

1. Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) – Offer tax advantages but have strict holding requirements.
2. Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs) – More common but taxed as ordinary income upon exercise.

Tax Treatment of Stock Options

Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs)

• At Exercise:
  • The difference between the FMV and the strike price (known as the "bargain element") is taxed as ordinary income.
  • Subject to payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare).
• Upon Sale:
  • If the shares are held after exercise and later sold, any price increase is subject to capital gains tax (short-term if held for less than a year, long-term if held for more than a year).

Incentive Stock Options (ISOs)

• At Exercise:
  • No immediate ordinary income tax, but the bargain element may be subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT).
• Upon Sale:
  • If held for at least two years from the grant date and one year from the exercise date, profits are taxed at long-term capital gains rates rather than ordinary income rates.
  • If these conditions are not met, the sale is considered a disqualifying disposition, and the gain is taxed as ordinary income.

Example:
John receives NSOs with a strike price of $20 per share. When he exercises them, the stock price is $50. He must report $30 per share as ordinary income. If he later sells the shares for $60, the additional $10 per share is taxed as capital gains.

Key Differences Between RSUs and Stock Options

Which Is Better for Tax Efficiency?

• RSUs are ideal if you prefer a lower-risk approach since they guarantee shares without requiring a purchase. However, they create immediate taxable income upon vesting.
• Stock options (ISOs) are preferable if you anticipate stock price growth and can hold shares long enough to benefit from long-term capital gains tax treatment. However, they involve financial risk, and ISOs may trigger AMT liabilities.

Tax Strategies to Minimize Liabilities

1. For RSUs:
   • Sell immediately upon vesting to avoid capital gains tax.
   • Set aside money for taxes, as they can significantly impact take-home pay.
2. For Stock Options:
   • Hold ISOs for the required period to qualify for long-term capital gains tax.
   • Time the exercise of NSOs in lower-income years to reduce tax impact.
   • Consult a tax professional to navigate AMT implications for ISOs.

Conclusion

RSUs and stock options are valuable equity compensation tools, but their tax treatment differs significantly. While RSUs provide guaranteed shares with immediate tax obligations, stock options offer the potential for long-term tax benefits but come with financial risk. Understanding how each is taxed allows employees to make informed decisions about when to exercise, sell, or hold their shares.

Tax Partners can help you navigate the complexities of RSU and stock option taxation to ensure compliance and minimize tax liabilities.

This article is written for educational purposes.

Should you have any inquiries, please do not hesitate to contact us at (905) 836-8755, via email at [email protected], or by visiting our website at www.taxpartners.ca.

Tax Partners has been operational since 1981 and is recognized as one of the leading tax and accounting firms in North America. Contact us today for a FREE initial consultation appointment.