Canada vs. U.S.: How Are Cryptocurrency Gains Taxed?

Introduction

Cryptocurrency taxation varies significantly between Canada and the U.S., making it essential for crypto traders and investors to understand their tax obligations. While both countries treat cryptocurrencies as property rather than currency, their approaches to capital gains, income classification, and reporting requirements differ. This guide explores how crypto gains are taxed in Canada vs. the U.S. and the key differences that investors should be aware of.

How Canada Taxes Cryptocurrency Gains

In Canada, cryptocurrency is classified as a commodity under the Income Tax Act, meaning transactions involving crypto are treated similarly to barter transactions. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) taxes crypto gains in two main ways:

1. Capital Gains Tax

• If crypto is bought and sold as an investment, it is subject to capital gains tax.
• Only 50% of the capital gains are taxable.
• The tax rate depends on the investor's marginal income tax bracket.

Example:

Sarah buys Bitcoin for $10,000 and later sells it for $18,000. Her capital gain is $8,000. Since only 50% of capital gains are taxable, she will report $4,000 as taxable income.

2. Business Income Tax

If an individual engages in frequent trading, staking, mining, or operates a crypto business, the CRA may classify the activity as a business income rather than a capital gain.

• 100% of the profits are taxable.
• The applicable tax rate depends on the individual's personal tax bracket or corporate tax rate (if registered under a corporation).

Example:

John is a crypto day trader and makes $50,000 from trading Bitcoin in a year. Since this is considered business income, the entire $50,000 is taxable at his marginal tax rate.

Additional Crypto Tax Considerations in Canada

• Crypto mining: The CRA treats mining rewards as either business income or capital gains, depending on the scale of operations.
• NFTs (Non-Fungible Tokens): Buying, selling, and trading NFTs are taxable, with the gains either treated as capital gains or business income.
• Crypto gifts & donations: Crypto received as a gift may be taxable depending on how it's used. If donated to a registered charity, a tax receipt can be issued.
• GST/HST Considerations: If crypto is used in a business, GST/HST rules may apply.

How the U.S. Taxes Cryptocurrency Gains

In the U.S., cryptocurrency is classified as property by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), meaning all transactions involving crypto must be reported for tax purposes.

1. Capital Gains Tax

Crypto sales, exchanges, and trades are subject to capital gains tax based on the holding period:

• Short-Term Capital Gains (held <1 year): Taxed as ordinary income (10%–37% based on tax bracket).
• Long-Term Capital Gains (held >1 year): Taxed at preferential rates of 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on total income.

Example:

Emma buys Ethereum for $5,000 and sells it for $9,000 after holding it for 14 months. Her gain is $4,000, taxed at the long-term capital gains rate (typically 15% for most taxpayers).

2. Ordinary Income Tax on Crypto Activities

Some crypto transactions are not treated as capital gains and are instead taxed as ordinary income at federal and state tax rates:

• Mining rewards
• Staking rewards
• Airdrops
• Earning crypto as payment for services

Example:

Mark receives 0.5 BTC as a mining reward when Bitcoin is valued at $30,000. He must report $15,000 as ordinary income on his tax return.

Additional Crypto Tax Considerations in the U.S.

• Crypto gifts: Not taxable for the recipient, but gifts above $18,000 (2024 threshold) may be subject to gift tax for the giver.
• Crypto donations: Donating to a qualified charity can allow investors to deduct the fair market value from their taxable income.
• Tax-loss harvesting: Losses from crypto investments can be used to offset capital gains and reduce tax liability.

Canada vs. U.S.: Key Differences in Crypto Taxation

How to Report Crypto Taxes in Canada and the U.S.

Canada

• Schedule 3 (Capital Gains) for investment-related crypto transactions.
• Form T2125 (Statement of Business or Professional Activities) for crypto businesses and mining operations.

United States

• Form 8949 & Schedule D: Used for reporting capital gains and losses.
• Schedule 1 (Form 1040): Used to report income from staking, mining, and airdrops.
• Form 1099-B / 1099-MISC: Crypto exchanges may issue these forms, summarizing transaction history.

Tax Strategies to Minimize Crypto Tax Liability

Regardless of whether you're in Canada or the U.S., you can implement several strategies to legally reduce your tax burden:

Long-Term Holding – In the U.S., holding crypto for over one year qualifies for lower capital gains tax rates.
Tax-Loss Harvesting – Sell losing positions to offset capital gains. This works in both countries.
Use the Foreign Tax Credit – If you’re a U.S. expat living in Canada, use Form 1116 to claim credit for foreign taxes paid
Consider TFSA/RRSP (Canada Only) – While crypto cannot be held in TFSAs or RRSPs, you can offset capital gains by making registered investments in other assets.

Conclusion

Crypto investors in both Canada and the U.S. must stay aware of their tax reporting obligations to remain compliant with tax authorities. The CRA and IRS have increased scrutiny on cryptocurrency transactions, making it crucial to track gains, losses, and income correctly.

If you need assistance with crypto tax compliance, Tax Partners can help you navigate the complexities of crypto taxation in Canada and the U.S

This article is written for educational purposes.

Should you have any inquiries, please do not hesitate to contact us at (905) 836-8755, via email at [email protected], or by visiting our website at www.taxpartners.ca.

Tax Partners has been operational since 1981 and is recognized as one of the leading tax and accounting firms in North America. Contact us today for a FREE initial consultation appointment.